HowreliableUsed car reliability from every MOT
CarsComparisonsTesla Model 3 vs Model Y
Head to head · latest DVSA data · Great Britain

Tesla Model 3 vs Model Y: which is more reliable?

The Model 3. Once age and mileage are allowed for, Model 3s pass the MOT first time 2.5 points more often than Model Ys. That's for cars registered in 2022: Model Ys from earlier years have too few MOTs to count. No registration year of either passes 1.5 or more points more often than the average car. Avoid Model 3s registered in 2020, and Model Ys registered in 2022.

Tesla Model 3 vs Model Y at a glance

Tesla Model 3Tesla Model Y
Passed first time, cars registered in 202285.3%83.8%
Against the average car of the same age and mileage−0.6 points−3.1 points
Years to avoid20202022
Best yearsNone stand outNone stand out
Fails most often, against the average carTyres: 2.0 times as oftenSuspension: 2.6 times as often
Most common failureTread depth below requirements of 1.6mmTyre damage: has a cut in excess of the requirements deep enough to reach the ply or cords
MOTs in 202586,63832,483

Model 3 and Model Y years to avoid

How often cars from each registration year passed the MOT first time, against the average car of the same age and mileage. The figure is the difference in percentage points.

First-time passes against the average car of the same age and mileage, in percentage points

Each block is a registration year: the year the car was first used. Tap or hover over one for its figures. Blank means too few MOTs that year.

Buying a particular year

Points against the average car of the same age and mileage, with each year's most common failure. Less than 1.5 points apart counts as either.

RegisteredModel 3Model YBetter bet
2019+0.3Tread depth below requirements of 1.6mmToo few MOTs
2020−1.9Tread depth below requirements of 1.6mmToo few MOTs
2021+0.6Tread depth below requirements of 1.6mmToo few MOTs
2022−0.6Tread depth below requirements of 1.6mm−3.1Tyre damage (has a cut in excess of the requirements deep enough to reach the ply or cords)Model 3

At higher mileage, and by fuel

How often each passed the MOT first time against the average car of the same age and mileage, in points. On cars with 60,000 to 90,000 miles, Model 3s passed the MOT first time 0.3 points less often than the average car of the same age and mileage, and Model Ys 0.8 points less often.

By mileage at the test

Model 3Model YBetter bet
Under 30k miles−0.5−3.3Model 3
30–60k miles−0.9−3.4Model 3
60–90k miles−0.3−0.8Either

By fuel

Model 3Model YBetter bet
Electric−0.3−3.1Model 3

Each fuel is compared with the average car of the same age and mileage, whatever its fuel. Rows with fewer than 500 MOTs for either car are left out.

Where they fail

Where each one fails at the MOT

How often each failed on every area of the test, against the average car of the same age and mileage. All registration years.

How often it failed on that area, against the average car of the same age and mileage
AreaModel 3: failedAgainst averageModel Y: failedAgainst average
Suspension2.4%1.5×2.2%2.6×
Steering0.0%0.1×0.0%0.2×
Brakes0.7%0.3×0.5%0.3×
Tyres11.2%2.0×12.2%2.1×
Lights & electrics1.8%0.5×1.5%0.5×
Visibility1.2%0.4×1.0%0.4×
Body & structure0.1%0.2×0.1%0.2×
Emissions & leaks0.0%0.0×0.0%0.0×
What fails

Model 3 and Model Y common faults at the MOT

The failures testers found most often on each, against the average car of the same age and mileage. Both charts use the same scale.

Tesla Model 3

Tesla Model Y

Check these before you buy

What testers most often noted as advisories on each: wear that passed but was close to failing. Figures in brackets are for the average car of the same age and mileage.

The verdict

The Model 3

Among cars registered in 2022, Model 3s passed the MOT first time 0.6 points less often than the average car of the same age and mileage, and Model Ys 3.1 points less often. That leaves the Model 3 ahead by 2.5 points.

Tesla Model 3More reliable

−0.6points against the average car of the same age and mileage

Best years
None stand out
Avoid
2020
Watch for
Tyres: fails 2.0 times as often as the average car
Full Model 3 report →

Tesla Model Y

−3.1points against the average car of the same age and mileage

Best years
None stand out
Avoid
2022
Watch for
Suspension: fails 2.6 times as often as the average car
Full Model Y report →

Questions

Is the Tesla Model 3 more reliable than the Tesla Model Y?

Going by the MOT, the Model 3 is. Among cars registered in 2022, 85.3% of Model 3s passed the MOT first time, against 83.8% of Model Ys. Once age and mileage are allowed for, the Model 3 comes out 2.5 points ahead.

Which Tesla Model 3 years should I avoid?

Going by 2025 MOT results, 2020. Those cars passed first time −1.9 points against the average car of the same age and mileage.

Which Tesla Model Y years should I avoid?

Going by 2025 MOT results, 2022. Those cars passed first time −3.1 points against the average car of the same age and mileage.

Which is better at high mileage, the Model 3 or the Model Y?

On cars with 60,000 to 90,000 miles, Model 3s passed the MOT first time 0.3 points less often than the average car of the same age and mileage, and Model Ys 0.8 points less often. That's too close to call.

What fails most often on each?

Model 3: tread depth below requirements of 1.6mm, on 4.8% of MOTs against 1.7% for the average car of the same age and mileage. Model Y: tyre damage (has a cut in excess of the requirements deep enough to reach the ply or cords), on 5.3% of MOTs against 2.3% for the average car of the same age and mileage.

More comparisons

How we compare

Data. Every car MOT in Great Britain in 2025, from DVSA's anonymised MOT data. That's 86,638 Model 3 MOTs and 32,483 Model Y MOTs, not counting retests.

Against the average car. We don't compare the two cars with each other directly. We compare each one with the average car of the same age and mileage, so a car doesn't win just because it's newer or has done fewer miles.

Which is more reliable. We look at cars registered in 2022 for both. Other comparisons use cars registered between 2014 and 2021, but Model Ys from those years have too few MOTs. If they're less than 1.5 points apart, there's no clear winner.

More on how we measure.